Monsignor Anthony J. Ferretti           1916 – 1957*
Rev. John Henry Banks                        1927 – 1951
Monsignor Joseph Carl Manz             1936 – 1948
Rev. Thomas A. Kenny                         1946 – 1952
Rev. Francis T. Gavin                            1948 – 1949
Rev. Robert F. Grady                            1948 – 1958
Rev. Henry J. Nicolaus                          1952 – 1958
Rev. William S. Sesselman                   1957 – 1975*
Rev. James J. Ferry                                1958 – 1962
Rev. Albert Matulis                               1958 – 1963
Rev. Thomas Petrillo                            1959 – 1960
Rev. Nicholas A. Carlino                       1960 – 1961
Rev. Alfonse Arminio                            1961 – 1975
Rev. Walter Cron                                   1962 – 1970
Rev. Edward McDermott                      1963 – 1975
Rev. Augustine Giella                            1970 – 1975
Rev. Patrick J. Leonard                          1975 – 1989‡
Rev. John F. Renard                               1975 – 1989‡
Monsignor Peter J. Zaccardo               1975 – 1982‡
Rev. Antonio S. Villar                             1979 – 1996‡
Rev. Robert P. Cozzini                           1982 – 2002‡
Rev. John F. Tully                                    1989 – 1991*
Rev. Thomas F. Olsen                            1991 – 2000*
Rev. Joseph Scarangella                       1996 – 2002
 Rev. Donald J. DiPasquale                     2000 – 2011*
Rev. Carlos Viego                                   2002 – 2003
Rev. Arnel Tadeo                                    2004 – 2006
Rev. Jungsoo Kim                                   2003 – 2006
Rev. Reynaldo Pardillada                      2006 – 2008
Rev. Frederick Pfeifer                            2006 – 2009
Rev. Miroslaw Kusibab                         2008 – 2014
     Rev. James G. Tucker                            2009 – Present
  Rev. Ken Evans                                      2011 – 2018*
     Rev. Bruce Harger                               2018 - Present*

* Pastor
‡ Team Minsitry